Skip to content

Check that your sources say what you say they say

  • Lesson 17 of 20
  • 7 min read
  • One step needs Plus

In this lesson you will

  • Compare a cited sentence with the passage it rests on
  • Read the four verdicts of the Citation report
  • Fix a sentence that claims more than its source

A citation supports a sentence only when the paper states the same thing, with the same strength. To check, open the source at the passage you relied on and compare it with your sentence. In Papero you can do this by hand with Show in PDF on a citation, or run the Citation report (part of Plus), which gives each cited sentence a verdict.

The three ways a citation goes wrong

The paper says less than you do. It found a link in one species and your sentence says "fish". Narrow the sentence to what was studied.

The paper says something else. You remembered it from the abstract of a different study. Find the right source or remove the claim.

The paper says it weaker. "May reduce" became "reduces" in your draft. Copy the strength of the original: may, in this sample, under these conditions.

A verdict from any tool is a reading aid, not proof. Read the passage yourself before you change or keep a citation.

Lines to copy

  • Too strongMicroplastics reduce growth in freshwater fish (Author et al., year).
  • As strong as the sourceIn one laboratory study, juvenile carp exposed to microplastics grew more slowly than a control group (Author et al., year).

In Papero

Set it up in Papero

By hand works on Free. The Citation report is part of Plus. It reads the full text when you added the PDF to your library, and the title and abstract otherwise.

  1. By hand: click a citation in your text. When the source has a PDF in your library, press Show in PDF to open it at the passage closest to your sentence.
    The panel that opens when you click a citation, with the Show in PDF button ringed beside Edit source and Remove.
  2. Read the passage and compare it with your sentence: same subject, same finding, same strength.
  3. With the report: press Side panel, then the Review tab, open More checks and find Citation report at the end of the list.
  4. Under What to check, keep Whole document or choose This section: with your cursor in a section. Press Check citations.
  5. Read Cited sentences, worst first. Each has one verdict: Not supported, Partly supported, Can't check or Supported.
  6. After a paper checked on its full text, press Show passages to read what the report read.

Practice

Your task

  1. Pick the three citations your argument leans on most.
  2. Open each source at the passage and compare it with your sentence.
  3. Reword any sentence that says more than its source, or find a better source.

You are done when for your three key citations you can point to the passage that backs each one. If you ran the report, no sentence is left under Not supported.

Common mistakes

  • Trusting the abstractAn abstract sums up. The result you cite, and its limits, are in the results section.
  • Treating Supported as proofThe verdict tells you where to look first. You still answer for the citation.
  • Checking without the PDFA check against an abstract is thin. Add the PDFs of the papers you rely on, then check again.

Key points

  • Same subject, same finding, same strength.
  • Start with the citations your argument depends on.
  • Add the PDF: the full text is a better test than the abstract.

Up next · Lesson 18 of 20 · 6 min

Get useful feedback on your draft

One weakness fixed and one comment from a reader

Mark as done and continue

Go deeper

Questions

How do I check that a source supports my claim?

Open the source at the passage you relied on and compare it with your sentence. The subject, the finding and the strength of the wording should match. If the paper says less, narrow your sentence.

What does Can't check mean?

There was nothing to check the sentence against, for example a paper with no abstract Papero can read, or the check failed. A note under the sentence says why. Adding the PDF of the paper usually fixes it.

Do I need Plus for this lesson?

No. Checking by hand works on Free: open each cited source and compare the passage with your sentence. The Citation report, which does a first pass for every cited sentence, is part of Plus.

What if I cannot find the passage?

Then you cannot rely on the citation. Search the paper for the key term. If the point is not there, look for a source that does make it, or remove the sentence.

Do the task while you read

Each lesson ends in one task in Papero. A free account is enough for all twenty.