Skip to content

Check your sources for retracted papers and preprints

  • Lesson 16 of 20
  • 5 min read
  • Works on Free

In this lesson you will

  • Say what a retraction and a preprint mean for your paper
  • Run the Sources check on your document
  • Replace or label each source it flags

Before you hand in, check that none of your sources was retracted and that you know which ones are preprints. In Papero, open the Review tab, open More checks and press Check sources. The result groups your sources under Retracted, Preprints, Rarely cited, Could not be checked and Looks fine.

Three labels and what to do about each

A retracted paper has been withdrawn by its journal, usually because of errors or misconduct. Do not use it as evidence. Find another study for the claim, or drop the claim.

A preprint has not been through peer review yet. You may cite one when nothing published covers the point, and many fields do. Look for a published version first, and say that it is a preprint when your style asks for it.

Rarely cited is a prompt to look, not a verdict. A paper from this year has had no time to be cited. An older one that nobody cites deserves a second read of its methods and of where it was published.

Lines to copy

  • Note to yourself after a retractionSource retracted. Claim on growth rates now rests on one study: find a second or soften the sentence.
  • Sentence that relies on a preprintA recent preprint, not yet peer reviewed, reports the same pattern in juvenile trout.

In Papero

Set it up in Papero

Works on Free. The check uses one review and counts toward the daily paper search limit that every plan has.

  1. Open your document and press Side panel, then the Review tab.
  2. Open More checks, find Sources and press Check sources. It reads the whole document.
    The Sources card in the Review tab, which checks for retracted papers, preprints and rarely cited ones, with Check sources ringed.
  3. Read the groups, starting with Retracted.
  4. Press Show in document on a flagged source to jump to where you cite it.
  5. For a retracted source, replace the citation or remove the claim. On Plus the reference list also marks the entry Retracted.
  6. Look at Could not be checked. A source with no DOI or OpenAlex record cannot be checked, so look those up yourself.

Practice

Your task

  1. Run the Sources check on your document.
  2. Deal with every source under Retracted.
  3. For each preprint, search for a published version and cite that when there is one.

You are done when the check shows nothing under Retracted, and you can say why each preprint is still in your list.

Common mistakes

  • Keeping a retracted paper for one small pointA marker who spots it will doubt the rest of your list. Replace it.
  • Deleting every rarely cited paperNew work is rarely cited yet. Judge the paper, not the count.
  • Ignoring what could not be checkedBooks, reports and web pages often have no DOI. Check those by hand: who published it, when, and is it still online.

Key points

  • Retracted: replace it. Preprint: look for the published version. Rarely cited: read it again.
  • The check reads the whole document in one go.
  • A source without a DOI needs your own check.

Up next · Lesson 17 of 20 · 7 min

Check that your sources say what you say they say

Every cited sentence backed by the paper it cites

Mark as done and continue

Go deeper

Questions

How do I know if a paper was retracted?

The journal page of the paper carries a retraction notice. In Papero, the Sources check lists retracted sources, on Plus the reference list marks them Retracted, and Cite warns you before you cite one from the search results.

Can I cite a preprint?

Often yes, when no published version exists and your field accepts it. Check your course or journal rules, look for a published version first, and make clear that it is a preprint.

What does rarely cited mean?

Few other papers have cited it so far. That is normal for recent work. For an older paper it is a reason to look again at how the study was done before you rely on it.

Why could a source not be checked?

The check needs a DOI or a record in OpenAlex to look the paper up. A source without either, such as some books and reports, is listed under Could not be checked.

Do the task while you read

Each lesson ends in one task in Papero. A free account is enough for all twenty.