What is a Systematic Review?
A systematic review answers a focused research question by finding, selecting, appraising and combining all the relevant studies, using a method set out in advance so that someone else could repeat it. Put simply: a literature review with a written recipe, designed to reduce bias. It is also called a systematic literature review, and it sits at the top of most evidence hierarchies in health and social policy.
Systematic Review vs Other Reviews
- Narrative review: flexible and interpretive, with no fixed protocol.
- Scoping review: systematic searching to map a broad field, usually without quality appraisal.
- Meta-analysis: the statistical pooling step that many systematic reviews include.
- Systematised or structured literature review: uses some systematic elements (a documented search, inclusion criteria) without the full method; common in student dissertations.
Steps in a Systematic Review
- Question: framed with PICO (Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome) or a similar scheme.
- Protocol: methods written and registered in advance, for example on PROSPERO.
- Search: a comprehensive search strategy using keywords, subject headings and Boolean operators across several databases, plus grey literature.
- Screening: titles, abstracts, then full texts against the criteria, usually by two reviewers independently.
- Data extraction: key details from each study into a standard form.
- Risk of bias: each study appraised with a tool such as Cochrane's RoB 2.
- Synthesis: narrative, or a meta-analysis if studies are similar enough; certainty rated, for example with GRADE.
- Reporting: following PRISMA 2020, with a flow diagram of how studies were selected.
Tools
Screening and extraction tools such as Covidence and Rayyan, reference managers for de-duplication, and the Cochrane Handbook for methods. Machine-learning screening aids exist, but each decision still needs human checking; general chatbots should not be used to find or summarise studies, as they can invent them.
Strengths and Limits
- Strengths: transparent, reproducible, less biased, and comprehensive.
- Limits: slow (often a year or more), and only as good as the studies available.
A shorter literature review for an essay can borrow the same habits: document your search and criteria (see literature review).