Skip to content

What is a Retraction?

What retraction means in academic publishing, why it happens, how it affects authors and researchers, and the ethical standards for handling it.

Sharing

What is a Retraction?

A retraction is a journal's formal statement that a published article should no longer be relied on, because its findings or its integrity cannot be trusted. The article usually stays online, clearly marked as retracted, with a retraction notice that explains why.

Why Retractions Occur

  • Data fabrication or falsification.
  • Plagiarism or duplicate publication.
  • Serious errors that invalidate the conclusions, even when made in good faith.
  • Ethical problems, such as missing consent or approval, or manipulated peer review.

The Retraction Process

  • Concerns reach the journal from readers, co-authors, institutions or the authors themselves.
  • The editors investigate, often following the COPE guidelines on publication ethics.
  • If the problem is confirmed, the journal publishes a retraction notice linked to the article, which stays available but is watermarked as retracted.

Retraction, Correction, Expression of Concern and Withdrawal

  • Correction: fixes an error that does not undermine the conclusions.
  • Expression of concern: a warning while an investigation is under way or its result is unclear.
  • Retraction: the conclusions cannot be relied on.
  • Withdrawal: usually removal before final publication, for example of an article in press or a preprint.

How to Check Whether a Paper Is Retracted

Look for a notice on the publisher's page, and search the Retraction Watch database, which Crossref acquired in 2023 and makes freely available. Zotero flags retracted items in your library automatically. Do not cite a retracted paper as evidence; if you discuss it, say that it was retracted.

Impact of Retraction

  • Retractions correct the scientific record and warn readers who might build on the work.
  • Retracted papers can go on being cited for years, which is why checking matters.
  • A retraction for honest error is a sign of responsible research ethics, not misconduct.

Free tool: Reference checker and citation checker

Use case: Find sources for every claim as you write

Your next paper, with real citations.

Describe your paper and get an outline in a minute. The Free plan needs no card.