What is Rejection in Academic Publishing?
A rejection is a journal's decision not to publish a submitted manuscript. It is the most common outcome in academic publishing: many journals reject most of what they receive, and leading journals reject over 90% (see acceptance rate). Almost every researcher has papers rejected; most rejected papers are later published elsewhere.
Types of Rejection
- Desk rejection: the editor declines without sending the paper for review, often within days, usually because it is out of scope, too preliminary, or does not follow the guidelines.
- Rejection after review: reviewers found problems too serious to fix in a revision.
- Reject and resubmit: the journal will look again at a substantially reworked version, as a new submission.
- Transfer offer: the publisher suggests a sister journal and can pass on the reviews.
Common Reasons for Rejection
- Poor fit with the journal's scope or readers.
- An unclear contribution: the paper does not say what is new.
- Weak design, small samples or unsupported conclusions.
- Unclear writing and structure.
- Ethical problems or missing approvals (see publication ethics).
What a Rejection Letter Says
Typical wording: "Thank you for submitting your manuscript. After careful consideration, we regret that we are unable to accept it for publication in the journal." A desk rejection often adds that the paper "falls outside the scope" or "is not of sufficient priority"; a rejection after review attaches the reviewers' reports.
What to Do After Rejection
- Allow yourself a day: rejection is discouraging, but it is a judgement of one paper at one journal, not of you.
- Read the reviews again and sort comments into those to act on and those that reflect the journal's preferences.
- Revise the manuscript, especially if reviewers raised the same problem.
- Choose the next journal for a better fit and reformat it to that journal's guidelines (see journal submission).
- Appeal only if the decision rests on a clear factual error; appeals rarely succeed otherwise.
Best Practices
- Keep a record of where each paper has been and the feedback received.
- Ask a colleague to read the paper with the reviews before resubmitting.
- Never resubmit to a new journal without updating the cover letter and formatting.
(This entry is about journal rejection; for revisions short of rejection, see revision request.)
Use case: AI writing tools for researchers