What is Double-Blind Peer Review?
In double-blind peer review (also called double-anonymous review), the reviewers do not know who wrote the manuscript and the authors do not know who reviewed it. The aim is for the work to be judged on its content alone, not on the authors' names, gender, country or institution. It is the norm in much of the humanities and social sciences, and an option at many science journals; Nature journals have offered it since 2015.
How It Works
- The author submits an anonymised manuscript, with names and affiliations on a separate title page.
- The editorial office checks the anonymisation and sends the paper to reviewers (see peer review).
- Reviewers report to the editor without learning who the authors are.
- The editor passes the reports to the authors, also anonymised.
Compare single-blind review, where reviewers can see the authors' names.
How to Anonymise Your Manuscript
- Remove names, affiliations and contact details from the main file.
- Take out or blind the acknowledgements and funding statements until acceptance.
- Cite your own earlier work in the third person ("Lee (2021) showed"), or as "Author (2021)" if the journal asks.
- Remove identifying details from the methods, such as the name of your university's ethics committee.
- Clear the author name from the file's properties (metadata) and tracked changes.
Each journal's submission guidelines say exactly what they require.
Common Questions
How do I check if a journal is peer-reviewed?
Read the journal's "About" or author guidelines page, which states its review model, or check a directory such as Ulrichsweb or a peer-reviewed database.
How long does peer review take?
Usually weeks to months: a first decision often takes one to three months, and the full process with revisions can take six months or more, depending on the field and journal.
Is "peer review" hyphenated?
Not as a noun ("the peer review was quick"); yes as an adjective before a noun ("a peer-reviewed journal").
Limits
In small fields, reviewers can often guess the authors from the topic, data or preprints already online. Double-blind review reduces bias but cannot remove it entirely.
Use case: AI writing tools for researchers