What is a Dangling Modifier?
A dangling modifier is a phrase that describes a person or thing the sentence never names, so it attaches itself, by grammar, to the wrong word. "Walking into the lab, the smell was overwhelming" says that the smell walked in.
How It Appears in a Sentence
Dangling modifiers usually open the sentence: an -ing phrase ("Having finished the survey,"), an -ed phrase ("Based on the results,") or an infinitive ("To improve accuracy,"). Readers expect the subject straight after the comma to be the one doing it. When the subject is something else, the modifier dangles.
Examples and Corrections
- Dangling: "Using a questionnaire, the data were collected from 200 students." (The data did not use the questionnaire.)
Fixed: "Using a questionnaire, we collected data from 200 students." - Dangling: "After reviewing the literature, a gap became clear."
Fixed: "After reviewing the literature, I identified a gap." - Dangling: "To reduce bias, participants were randomly assigned."
Fixed: "To reduce bias, we assigned participants at random."
Methods sections are full of them because the passive voice hides the people doing the work. Switching to the active voice usually fixes the sentence.
How to Change a Dangling Modifier
- Ask who or what is doing the action in the opening phrase.
- Make that the subject of the main clause, straight after the comma.
- Or turn the phrase into a full clause with its own subject: "When we reviewed the literature, a gap became clear."
Dangling vs Misplaced Modifiers
A misplaced modifier describes something that is in the sentence, but sits too far from it: "She served cake to the guests on paper plates." (The guests were not on the plates.) Fix it by moving the modifier: "She served the guests cake on paper plates." A dangling modifier has nothing to attach to; a misplaced one is attached to the wrong neighbour. Single-word modifiers, such as adverbs like "only", can be misplaced too.
Final Tips
When proofreading, stop at every sentence that opens with an -ing, -ed or "to" phrase and check the first noun after the comma. It is one of the most common faults in otherwise careful sentence structure.